Smart Woman Gold is paid by some of the companies it covers when readers contact them. Plain information, never personal financial advice. Our disclosure

Goldco vs Augusta vs American Hartford Gold: 2026 Comparison

Goldco, Augusta Precious Metals and American Hartford Gold sell the same kind of thing: physical gold and silver for self-directed IRAs and for delivery outside one. Where they differ is in who they take on, what they promise when you sell, and how much they tell you up front. This page lines up what each company publishes, as read on its own pages and its BBB profile on 2026-11-19, so you can see which one fits your order.

Quick answer: Choose by order size first. Augusta states a $50,000 minimum for IRA and cash orders; Goldco states $25,000 for an IRA and $10,000 for a direct purchase; American Hartford Gold states $10,000 for a gold IRA. Then compare buyback wording: only Goldco publishes a highest-price guarantee, and it applies after three years.

Key takeaways

  • Minimums sort most readers before anything else: American Hartford Gold opens IRAs from $10,000, Goldco from $25,000 and Augusta from $50,000.
  • American Hartford Gold names its custodian (Equity Trust Company) and preferred depositories; Augusta names neither; Goldco says it works with all major self-directed IRA custodians and names no depository.
  • Buyback language ranges from a conditional guarantee (Goldco) to a quote "if Augusta agrees to repurchase" (Augusta) to a three-step "commitment" (American Hartford Gold).
  • All three hold BBB A+ grades, and each has a Minnesota dealer-registration order on record or probably on record.

Quick Verdict

For most readers moving a five-figure retirement account, Goldco is our pick: its minimums are published, it handles IRA and direct purchases, and its buyback terms, condition included, are in writing. Augusta suits larger orders from people who want a structured, education-first process before buying. American Hartford Gold suits smaller IRAs and readers who want the custodian and depository named before they call.

Side-by-Side: What Each Company Publishes

Every cell below comes from the company's own pages or its BBB profile. We left out fees on purpose: online fee figures go stale, and the only reliable ones are those a company writes down for your order.

What we checkedGoldcoAugusta Precious MetalsAmerican Hartford Gold
Started2011, per BBB2012, per Augusta2015, per the company
Stated minimum$25,000 IRA; $10,000 direct purchase$50,000, IRA or personal funds$10,000 gold IRA; none stated for direct
IRA and cash purchasesBothBothBoth
Custodian named"All major" self-directed custodians; FAQ refers to Equity Trust statementsNone namedEquity Trust Company
Depository namedNone namedNone namedBrink's Global Services, Delaware Depository; also International Depository Services
Buyback wordingWill buy back at any time; highest-price guarantee after three years; no specific rates guaranteedLive quote if it agrees to repurchase; 24 hours to seek a higher outside bid; future prices not guaranteed"Buyback Commitment," three steps; no price guarantee stated
Kit or offerFree gold and silver kit; free silver on qualifying ordersFree Gold & Silver IRA Info Kit, "4 essential guides"; says it offers no free silverFree 2027 Gold & Silver Preservation Guide; free-silver amounts differ between its pages
BBB (read 2026-11-19)A+, accredited since 2011; 75 complaints in 3 yearsA+, accredited since 2015; 1 complaint in 3 yearsA+, accredited since 2016; 116 complaints in 3 years

Goldco's promotion of free silver on qualifying orders* is Goldco's own, applies only when a purchase qualifies, and is governed by the terms reproduced below the article. BBB figures come from a summary of each profile, so confirm them in a browser.

Pick Goldco If...

  • Your IRA order is $25,000 or more, or your direct purchase is $10,000 or more, and you want one company for both.
  • You value written buyback terms. In a note on its site, Goldco commits to repurchasing metal it sold you at any point. Its highest-price guarantee "applies after three years from initial purchase," and it states "No specific buy back rates guaranteed." If you plan to hold for at least three years, that condition may not matter much; if you might sell sooner, it does.
  • You already have a custodian in mind. Goldco says it works with all major self-directed IRA custodians rather than steering everyone to one.

Goldco is a weaker fit if you want the depository named before the first call (ask for it in writing), or if its complaint count gives you pause. BBB lists 75 complaints in the last three years and 37 in the last 12 months. Our Is Goldco legit? page goes through the record, and the Goldco review covers products and process.

Pick Augusta If...

  • Your order is $50,000 or more. Augusta's FAQ applies that floor to IRA purchases and purchases with personal funds alike, and says the whole amount goes toward buying metal.
  • You want to learn before you're sold to. Augusta describes a required one-on-one web conference before any product discussion, led by what it calls a salaried educator, and says funding an account "does not obligate you to purchase metals."
  • You prefer a company that skips promotions. Augusta states that it "does not offer free silver" and tells consumers to steer clear of those promotions. That is Augusta's opinion about other companies, not ours.

Augusta is the wrong fit below $50,000. It also names no custodian or depository on its FAQ, so ask which ones it uses. On buyback, it gives a live quote if it agrees to repurchase, and customers have 24 hours after the recorded confirmation call to seek a higher outside bid and cancel. It also states: "Future repurchases and prices are not guaranteed." See the Augusta Precious Metals review.

Pick American Hartford Gold If...

  • Your IRA order is between $10,000 and $25,000. Of the three, only American Hartford Gold states a gold IRA minimum that low.
  • You want names before you call. It names Equity Trust Company as custodian and recommends Brink's Global Services or Delaware Depository, with Brink's facilities in Los Angeles and Salt Lake City and Delaware Depository in Wilmington.
  • You want short-term protections in writing. Its About page describes a Price Protection Guarantee (a credit in additional coins if its selling price on a qualifying purchase drops within 7 calendar days) and a 7-day satisfaction guarantee, with full terms in its Shipping and Transaction Agreement.

It is a weaker fit if you want a price written into the buyback promise; the company calls its version a "commitment" and states no guaranteed price. Its BBB profile lists 116 complaints in the last three years and 42 in the last 12 months. See the American Hartford Gold review.

Goldco vs Augusta

The first difference is the floor. A reader with $30,000 in an old 401(k) can open a Goldco IRA but sits below Augusta's stated $50,000. Above $50,000, both are options and the comparison turns on style and terms.

Process. Augusta builds its approach around education: learn, talk to an educator, then decide, with a required web conference first. Goldco markets speed, with a "1 DAY IRA" promise on its About page, and says a rollover typically takes less than two weeks. Neither is better in the abstract. If you want time and structure before a purchase, Augusta's sequence provides it; if you already know what you want, Goldco's may feel less drawn out.

Buyback. Goldco's guarantee is clearer on paper but conditional: highest price after three years, no specific rates. Augusta makes no general guarantee to repurchase and says future prices are not guaranteed, but it offers a 24-hour window to seek a higher bid once a sale is confirmed. Ask each for its buyback terms in writing and read them together.

Offers. Goldco runs a free-silver promotion with conditions; Augusta says it offers none and warns against them. Read Goldco's terms and judge the offer on what you would actually buy.

Record. Both are BBB A+. BBB lists 75 complaints in three years for Goldco and 1 for Augusta, though counts partly reflect how many customers a company serves, which BBB doesn't show. Both have Minnesota consent orders over dealer registration: Goldco Direct, LLC in 2018 with a $5,000 civil penalty, and Augusta in 2019 with a $3,000 civil penalty. Neither order was a fraud finding.

Goldco vs American Hartford Gold

These two overlap the most: both sell for IRAs and direct delivery, and both serve smaller orders than Augusta.

Minimums. American Hartford Gold's $10,000 gold IRA floor is lower than Goldco's $25,000. For direct purchases, Goldco states $10,000 and American Hartford Gold states nothing on the pages we read.

Transparency on custody. American Hartford Gold names its custodian and depositories; Goldco names neither a single custodian nor a depository. If knowing exactly where the metal will sit matters to you, that favours American Hartford Gold, or a written answer from Goldco.

Buyback. Goldco's highest-price guarantee, once three years have passed, is a stronger written promise than a "commitment" with no stated price. American Hartford Gold's 7-day price protection, on the other hand, covers the period right after you buy, which Goldco's guarantee does not.

Offers. Both advertise free silver. Goldco prints terms; American Hartford Gold's homepage and promotions page give different maximum amounts and we found no terms on either, so we don't repeat a figure.

Record. Both are BBB A+. BBB lists 75 complaints in three years for Goldco and 116 for American Hartford Gold. Minnesota entered a 2018 consent order against Goldco Direct, LLC over registration. Minnesota's database also lists two 2017 consent orders against "Hartford Gold Group"; BBB lists that name as an alternate name of American Hartford Gold, but we have not confirmed it is the same company.

Augusta vs American Hartford Gold

These two sit at opposite ends of the minimum range, so few readers will weigh them against each other.

Who they serve. Augusta starts at $50,000; American Hartford Gold's gold IRA starts at $10,000. If your order is under $50,000, the choice is made for you.

Process. Augusta requires a web conference with an educator before discussing products. American Hartford Gold assigns what it calls a dedicated Precious Metals Specialist "for the life of their account," and says opening a gold IRA generally takes one business day.

Custody. American Hartford Gold names Equity Trust Company and its preferred depositories; Augusta names neither on its FAQ.

Short-term protections. Both describe 7-day protections for eligible purchases under their own terms. Augusta notes that "not every order has the same protections," and American Hartford Gold points to its Shipping and Transaction Agreement. Ask each which protections apply to your order.

Record. Augusta: BBB A+, 1 complaint in three years, and a 2019 Minnesota registration consent order with a $3,000 civil penalty. American Hartford Gold: BBB A+, 116 complaints in three years, and the 2017 Minnesota orders described above.

Questions That Decide It for You

Put the same questions to each company you're considering, and ask for the answers in writing.

  1. What is the minimum for this type of account, and does this order meet it?
  2. Which custodian and which depository will hold the metal? Have them named in the paperwork.
  3. What exactly does the buyback promise, and from what date? Ask how a sale in year one would be priced.
  4. What will this order cost in total? The CFTC's checklist asks for every charge and the agreed retail price in writing before you sign.
  5. Has the custodian confirmed each product is IRA-eligible? The tax code ties bullion to the fineness a futures exchange requires; custodians decide which products they accept.
  6. What does the company's public record show? Check BBB and the Minnesota Commerce enforcement search yourself.

Our homepage has a fuller checklist of questions to ask, and the best gold IRA ranking explains how we scored all three. If you are still learning how the account works, start with our guide to buying gold in an IRA.

FAQ

Which company has the lowest minimum?

American Hartford Gold, at $10,000 for a gold IRA. Goldco states $25,000 for an IRA and $10,000 for a direct purchase. Augusta states $50,000 for either.

Which company names its custodian?

American Hartford Gold names Equity Trust Company. Goldco says it works with all major self-directed IRA custodians, and Augusta refers only to an independent custodian.

Does any of them guarantee a buyback price?

Goldco's highest-price buyback guarantee applies after three years from the first purchase, with no specific rates guaranteed. Augusta says future repurchases and prices are not guaranteed. American Hartford Gold describes a buyback commitment without a stated price.

Can I keep the metal at home with any of them?

Not inside an IRA. All three say IRA metal goes to an approved depository, and the IRS treats IRA coins the owner takes possession of as distributed. Metal bought outside an IRA can be delivered to you.

Why don't you compare fees?

Fee figures found online are often wrong or out of date. Ask each company for every charge in writing for the same order, then compare.

Sources

Partner links on this page can earn Smart Woman Gold a commission; that never changes the facts above. Read the disclosure.