Is Goldco Legit? Complaints, BBB Rating and Regulatory Record in 2026
Goldco is the company this site suggests. We are paid when readers contact it through our links, and that is exactly why this page exists: before you move retirement money anywhere, you deserve to see the complaints, the regulatory record and the lawsuits laid out plainly, with the source for each. Everything below was read on 2026-11-19 unless another date is given.
Quick answer: Yes, Goldco is a real, established dealer: BBB lists it as started in 2011 and rates it A+. Its record also includes a 2018 Minnesota consent order over dealer registration, a settled class action over marketing texts, and customer complaints about slow call-backs and the prices paid for premium coins. No federal enforcement action naming it turned up.
Key takeaways
- Per its BBB profile (read 2026-11-19), Goldco has an A+ grade, has been accredited since 2011, and lists 75 complaints in the past three years.
- In the 20 most recent BBB complaints, the leading themes were delays reaching staff or selling metal, and disputes over what customers paid for premium coins.
- Minnesota entered a consent order in 2018 because Goldco Direct sold bullion there before registering; it paid a $5,000 civil penalty. No fraud finding was made.
- A 2023 class action alleged marketing texts after stop requests. Goldco denied it and agreed to a settlement.
- We found no CFTC, SEC, FTC or Justice Department action naming Goldco.
The Short Answer
"Legit" can mean two different things. It can mean the company is real, registered where it needs to be, and delivers what it sells. Or it can mean something closer to "is this a good deal for someone like me?" The public record can answer the first question fairly well. The second depends on the price you agree to, the products you buy and how long you plan to hold them, and only you can weigh that.
On the first question, the record points one way: more than a decade in business, a top BBB grade, complaints answered in public, and no federal enforcement action we could find. On the second, the complaints deserve a careful read, because the same themes keep returning.
Who Goldco Is
BBB lists the business as started on October 26, 2011, organised as a limited liability company, with "Goldco Direct LLC" as an alternate name. The address on its BBB profile is in Calabasas, California.
Goldco's careers page says Trevor Gerszt started the company. BBB lists him as Founder/CEO, along with Jennifer Stearns as General Counsel and JD Koehler as President.
Goldco describes itself as a precious metals company that helps Americans protect retirement savings with gold and silver. It offers two routes: metals held in a self-directed IRA, and direct purchases delivered to you. Its published minimums, from the FAQ on its gold and silver IRA pages, are "$10,000 – Direct Purchase / $25,000 – IRA". If your rollover is smaller than that, Goldco is not set up for your order.
BBB Profile and Other Ratings
Per its BBB profile, read 2026-11-19:
| Item | What the profile shows |
|---|---|
| Grade | A+ |
| Accredited since | December 9, 2011 |
| Complaints, past 3 years | 75 |
| Complaints, past 12 months | 37 |
| Customer reviews | 4.82 out of 5, from 1,718 reviews |
| Local BBB | BBB of Los Angeles & Silicon Valley |
Two things are worth knowing about those numbers. A BBB letter grade weighs things like complaint handling and time in business; it says nothing about whether the coins are good value. And BBB says itself that the nature of complaints and a company's responses often matter more than the count.
On Trustpilot, Goldco showed 4.4 stars from 1,798 reviews on November 19, 2026. The profile is marked as claimed by the company and as a paid Trustpilot subscription, and Trustpilot states that it doesn't fact-check reviews. Its automated summary says reviewers praise the staff and service, and that negative comments most often concern price.
Goldco's own homepage says Business Consumer Alliance rates it Triple A. We could not open that profile to confirm it, and the ConsumerAffairs page about Goldco refused our request, so we report neither rating as checked.
What Complaints Say: the Recurring Themes
We read the 20 most recent complaints published on Goldco's BBB profile, dated February 6 to August 25, 2026. The other 55 from the past three years were not read, so treat these counts as a sample, not a census. Everything in this section is what customers have alleged; BBB does not verify complaint narratives. One complaint can touch more than one theme.
| Theme | Complaints out of 20 |
|---|---|
| Delays selling, liquidating or withdrawing metal, and calls not returned | 11 |
| Disputes over the price paid for premium or collectible coins versus their melt or buyback value | 8 |
| Unwanted sales calls or emails | 2 |
| Problems shipping metal back for a buyback | 1 |
Delays and call-backs. Customers have complained about waiting weeks for a call back or for sale proceeds, about an automated phone system, and in one case about trying to confirm they had been added to an inherited account. Most of these were dated in the first months of 2026. In its published replies, Goldco cites unusually high call volumes across the industry, including at custodians and depositories, and says it tried to reach the customer or that a manager spoke with them.
What customers paid. Customers have complained that they paid far above the spot price, that their custodian statement shows a lower value than they expected, or that a buyback offer came in below what they paid. One said the coins received were not the ones described. Goldco's replies say custodian statements show the spot value of the metal rather than the value of the coins, and in several cases that its buyback offer was above the original purchase price.
This theme is the one to take most seriously before you buy, and it has a plain explanation. The spot price is the market price for raw metal. A dealer, any dealer, sells above spot and buys back below it, as the CFTC explains in its guide to buying physical metals. Premium and collectible coins sit further above spot than plain bullion. If you buy them and later read a statement that values them at melt, the gap can be a shock.
Unwanted contact. Two customers said they kept getting calls after asking for a brochure, or that an unsubscribe link didn't work. Goldco says it removed their details, and in one case that it had no record of the person.
Status. Goldco responded to all 20. Two were marked "Resolved"; the rest were marked "Answered", and in several of those the customer rejected the response.
The buyback condition. Several of these complaints involve selling metal back. Goldco says it "will buy back metals purchased from Goldco at any time", but its "highest price buy back guarantee applies after three years from initial purchase", and it adds: "No specific buy back rates guaranteed." If you might need to sell within three years, ask how the buyback price would be worked out in your case.
Regulatory Record
Minnesota, 2018. In May 2018 Minnesota's Department of Commerce entered a consent order against Goldco Direct, LLC. The order found that Goldco had sold bullion products to Minnesota consumers in amounts "substantially exceeding statutory thresholds" before registering as a bullion dealer with the department. Goldco agreed to a $5,000 civil penalty, and the order also required it to repay the department's investigative expenses. It was a registration matter; the order makes no fraud allegation.
For context, the same state database lists similar registration orders against several other large dealers, including Augusta Precious Metals in 2019. Minnesota's registration rule has caught a number of national sellers.
Federal regulators. We found no CFTC, SEC, FTC or Justice Department enforcement action naming Goldco. A search of the National Futures Association's BASIC database returned no entry for Goldco Direct; the only "Goldco" listed was an unrelated Florida firm that is not an NFA member. That is expected, since Goldco sells physical metal and is not a futures firm. An honest caveat: the federal checks were searches of the agencies' sites and the SEC's filing database, not a line-by-line read of every enforcement list.
California and Texas. Searches of the California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation website and the Texas state board's website returned no action naming Goldco as of November 19, 2026. In both cases a control search for a dealer with a known action did return results, so the searches were working.
Lawsuits: What Is and Isn't on Record
Federal court records list a handful of cases involving Goldco Direct. We read them through CourtListener's search pages; the individual docket pages were blocked to us, so several outcomes are unknown and we say so.
Summerton v. Goldco Direct LLC (W.D. Wis., No. 3:23-cv-00238). Filed in April 2023, this class action under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act alleged that Goldco sent more than one marketing text within 12 months to people who had asked it to stop. Goldco denied the allegations and any wrongdoing; the court-authorized notice says the court had not decided who was right. Goldco agreed to a settlement, and the notice describes a $2,000,000 settlement fund. A final approval hearing was set for March 26, 2026. We did not read the court's approval order, so we don't state its result.
Other telemarketing suits. Goldco has faced two other suits under the same law in federal court in Los Angeles. In the first, filed in 2019 (Judson v. Goldco Direct, No. 2:19-cv-06798), Goldco filed a notice of settlement in 2020; the terms were not public in the docket we read. The second, filed in July 2024 (Ashworth v. Goldco Direct, No. 2:24-cv-06144), was closed in September 2024, and the record we could see does not show how.
A 2021 New York case. Goldco Direct was one of the named parties in a 2021 federal case in New York brought mainly against another dealer, Lear Capital. It closed later that year. We could not see the claims against Goldco or how they ended.
Goldco as plaintiff. In 2018 Goldco itself sued a group of individuals and coin companies in federal court in Alabama under the federal racketeering statute, and one defendant filed a cross-claim against Goldco and its founder. The case closed in May 2019; the docket we could see does not show the outcome.
What we didn't find. No news report of a fraud suit against Goldco turned up. State courts were not searched.
A name that causes confusion. Court databases also list dozens of cases against unrelated companies called Goldco LLC, Goldco Inc. or Goldco Industries, many from before 2011, when BBB lists the dealer as incorporated. They have nothing to do with the precious metals dealer, so match the full company name before drawing conclusions.
Is the Free-Silver Offer Real?
Yes, in the sense that it is Goldco's own published promotion: free silver on qualifying orders.* The terms say it applies only to qualified orders, can't be combined with other offers, and that additional rules may apply; your representative confirms whether your order qualifies. The full terms are printed at the foot of this page.
Read them before you rely on the offer. Goldco's promotional page shows a table that doesn't match its own footnote on where the offer starts, so ask for the qualifying amount in writing. And keep the offer in proportion: free metal is part of the price you agree to, not a reason on its own to buy.
How to Check Any Gold Dealer Yourself
Anyone can run the checks we ran, and each takes minutes.
- BBB. Look up the exact company name. Read the complaints, not just the grade, and notice whether the same problem keeps recurring and how the company answers.
- Your state regulator. Many states register bullion dealers or police metals sales. Minnesota's Commerce enforcement search lets you type any dealer's name; your own state's financial regulator may have a similar search.
- NFA BASIC. If anyone offers you metals on margin, financing or leverage, check the firm in the NFA's BASIC database. A plain physical-metal dealer usually won't appear, and that by itself is not a warning sign.
- CFTC and SEC. Search the CFTC enforcement actions and SEC litigation releases for the company's name and its owners' names.
- Court records. A free docket search will show federal cases. Expect companies with similar names, and match the full legal name before reading anything into a result.
Two further points from the regulators. The SEC warns that the custodians of self-directed IRAs generally do not evaluate the quality or legitimacy of what goes into them, so a custodian's involvement is no seal of approval. And the CFTC tells buyers to get every cost and the agreed retail price in writing before signing a sales agreement. That applies to every dealer, including this site's pick.
For the steps of setting up the account itself, see how to buy gold in an IRA.
Verdict
The record shows a long-running, BBB-accredited dealer with an A+ grade, a single state registration order that several big competitors share, a settled class action over marketing texts, and no federal enforcement action we could find. It also shows a steady stream of customer complaints, most often about slow responses when people want to sell and about how much they paid for premium coins compared with what those coins are later worth.
What the record doesn't show: the outcome of every lawsuit, the 55 older BBB complaints we didn't read, or how any one customer's order was priced. Those gaps are real, and we'd rather you know them.
Our view is that Goldco is a legitimate company and a reasonable choice for a buyer who meets its stated minimum, intends to hold for years rather than months, and gets the quote, the product list and the buyback terms in writing before funding anything. If you want the full company profile, read our Goldco review. If you'd like to see alternatives side by side, compare Goldco, Augusta and American Hartford Gold or read our best gold IRA rankings.
FAQ
Is Goldco a scam?
Nothing we found suggests that. It has operated since 2011 per BBB, holds an A+ BBB grade, and has no federal enforcement action naming it that we could find. Its record does include a 2018 Minnesota registration order, a settled texting class action and recurring customer complaints, all described above.
What do customers complain about most?
In the 20 most recent BBB complaints, delays reaching staff or selling metal came up 11 times, and disputes over the price paid for premium coins came up 8 times. Goldco answered each one publicly.
Was Goldco fined by a regulator?
Minnesota's Department of Commerce entered a consent order in 2018 because Goldco Direct sold bullion to Minnesota consumers before registering as a dealer there. Goldco paid a $5,000 civil penalty. The order makes no fraud allegation.
Has Goldco been sued?
Yes. The largest is Summerton v. Goldco Direct LLC, a 2023 class action over marketing texts, which Goldco denied and settled. It has faced other telemarketing suits too, and several outcomes aren't visible in the dockets we could read.
Does Goldco guarantee to buy my metal back?
Goldco says it will buy back metal bought from it at any time, but its highest-price guarantee applies only after three years from the first purchase, and it states that no specific buyback rates are guaranteed.
Sources
- BBB profile: Goldco
- Trustpilot: Goldco
- Goldco: Start a Gold IRA (FAQ with minimums)
- Goldco: Start a Silver IRA (FAQ with minimums)
- Goldco: buyback guarantee terms
- Goldco: careers page (founder)
- Goldco: homepage (ratings it states)
- Minnesota Department of Commerce: enforcement search, Goldco
- Minnesota consent order: Goldco Direct, LLC (2018)
- Summerton v. Goldco Direct LLC: docket (CourtListener)
- Summerton v. Goldco Direct LLC: court-authorized notice (PDF)
- Summerton settlement website
- Judson v. Goldco Direct: docket (CourtListener)
- Ashworth v. Goldco Direct: docket (CourtListener)
- French v. Lear Capital: docket (CourtListener)
- Goldco Direct LLC v. Clackum: docket (CourtListener)
- NFA BASIC search
- California DFPI site search: "goldco"
- Texas state board site search: "goldco"
- CFTC enforcement actions
- SEC litigation releases
- SEC alert: self-directed IRAs (PDF)
- CFTC: questions to ask before buying physical metals
Partner links on this page can earn Smart Woman Gold a commission; that never changes the facts above. Read the disclosure.