This guide is for anyone deciding what to do with retirement money you now control: an old 401(k) from a job you left, an IRA you inherited, or savings you manage on your own. It explains how a gold or silver IRA actually works, what it can and can't do, and the questions worth asking before any money moves. Every fact here comes from a regulator, the tax code or the company's own pages, and each one is listed under Sources at the end.
Quick answer: A gold IRA is an individual retirement account, of the self-directed kind, that owns physical gold or silver in place of stocks and funds. A custodian runs the account, a dealer sells you the metal, and an approved depository stores it. The tax rules match other IRAs, but the costs, storage and selling steps are different.
Key takeaways
- A gold IRA is an ordinary IRA wrapper around unusual contents: coins or bars that only a custodian or trustee may hold, never you at home.
- Moving money in is usually done as a trustee-to-trustee transfer or a direct rollover, which avoids the tax traps of handling the cash yourself.
- Gold pays no interest or dividends and its price can fall for years at a time; it is one holding among several, not a guarantee.
- Our pick is Goldco, which publishes minimums of $25,000 for an IRA and $10,000 for a direct purchase. Its highest-price buyback guarantee starts three years after the first purchase.
We may be paid if you contact a company through links on this site; it never changes the facts we print. Our affiliate disclosure explains how.
What a Gold IRA Is, in Plain Words
Think of an IRA as a container with tax rules attached. A self-directed IRA is the same container with a wider menu, and a gold IRA is one that holds coins or bars of physical metal.
Three parties do the work, and it helps to know which is which before anyone calls you.
The custodian is the financial firm that holds the IRA itself. It keeps the records, sends your statements and reports to the IRS. The custodian is the legal owner of the metal on the account's behalf. Goldco's own homepage puts it plainly: "Your statement is provided by your IRA Custodian, not Goldco."
The dealer sells the metal to the account. Goldco is a dealer. Dealers often help you open the account with a custodian they work with, but the dealer and the custodian are separate businesses.
The depository is the vault where the coins or bars sit. IRA metal goes to an approved depository, not to your house.
That last point is not a preference. Under the tax code, buying a "collectible" inside an IRA counts as taking the money out, and the definition of collectible includes "any metal or gem" and "any stamp or coin." Gold and silver only fit in an IRA through a narrow exception in Section 408(m)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. It covers certain U.S. gold and silver coins, and gold, silver, platinum or palladium bullion that meets the fineness a regulated futures exchange sets for delivery, provided a trustee keeps the bullion in its physical possession. The statute prints no purity number; custodians and dealers decide which products they accept, so confirm eligibility with the custodian. The IRS repeats the possession rule in Publication 590-B: coins the owner takes into her own possession are treated as distributed.
So a gold IRA is less a product than an arrangement. The step-by-step guide to buying gold in an IRA walks through each stage in order.
Why Retirement Money Has to Last Longer Than You Might Think
A decision about gold rarely comes at the start of a working life. It usually arrives later, with the paperwork from an old plan or an estate on the table and a long stretch of retirement still ahead.
The first factor is time. According to the CDC's National Center for Health Statistics, someone who reached 65 in 2024 could expect to live about 18.4 more years on average if a man and 20.8 if a woman. Longer retirements mean more years of drawing money down and more years in which any single holding has to hold up.
The second is who ends up running the accounts. The Administration for Community Living reports, from Census data, that in 2023 about 29% of women and about 11% of men aged 65 and older were widowed: roughly 9 million widows and 2.9 million widowers. It can begin sooner than people plan for. In the Census Bureau's 2009 marital-history survey, the most recent published figure we found, the median age at widowhood from a first marriage was 59.4 for women and 61.1 for men.
Put together, those numbers describe a common moment: one partner, often in their late fifties or sixties, takes over an inherited IRA or a spouse's 401(k) and has to decide alone what it should hold for the next twenty years. Nothing in that calls for gold in particular. It does call for knowing what you are buying, who holds it, and how you would get the money back out, which is what the checklist below is for.
Questions to Ask Before You Move Retirement Money Into Metals
Keep this list beside the phone. A reputable company can answer every question, in writing.
- Is this a trustee-to-trustee transfer or a rollover, and who moves the money? The IRS allows only one IRA-to-IRA rollover in any 12-month period and gives you 60 days to complete one, while direct transfers between trustees are not limited that way.
- Which custodian will hold the account, and is it named in the paperwork? The custodian, not the dealer, is responsible for the account, and an SEC alert warns that self-directed IRA custodians "will generally not evaluate the quality or legitimacy" of what goes into the account.
- Which depository will store the metal, and is it stored in the account's name? The CFTC lists an agreement "that does not identify where the physical metal is located" as a warning sign of fraud.
- Has the custodian confirmed that every product on the order is IRA-eligible? If a coin or bar does not meet the tax code's exception, buying it inside the IRA can be treated as a taxable distribution.
- What will you pay in total, in writing: the price over spot on each product, plus setup, custodian and storage charges? The CFTC's checklist says to get every charge and the agreed retail price in writing before you sign anything.
- What is the company's minimum order, and does it fit the share of your savings you have in mind? A minimum is a floor the company sets for its own business, not a recommendation about how much of your money belongs in metal.
- What exactly does the buyback promise, and when does it start to apply? A buyback "program" and a guaranteed price are different things, and conditions such as waiting periods change what the promise is worth.
- Is anyone steering you toward collectible or "semi-numismatic" coins? Regulators at the CFTC and FINRA describe "semi-numismatic" as a made-up label with no special meaning, and say paying extra for it is likely a scam.
- How will required withdrawals work once you reach 73? The IRS says traditional IRA owners must begin required minimum distributions at 73, so ask the custodian how it handles them from an account that holds metal rather than cash.
- What does the company's public record show? A BBB profile and a state regulator's database take minutes to check, and FINRA tells buyers to "Check the background of the salesperson and company" first.
Gold vs Silver in an IRA
Both metals can sit in a self-directed IRA under the same exception, but they behave differently once they are there.
| Gold | Silver | |
|---|---|---|
| Coins the tax code names | U.S. gold coins of one, one-half, one-quarter and one-tenth ounce | The one-ounce U.S. silver coin |
| Bullion | Allowed at or above the fineness a futures market requires | Same rule |
| Price swings, 10 years to 2026-11-04 | About 17% annualised volatility | About 35%, roughly twice gold's |
| Worst fall since 2000 (COMEX closes) | 44.4%, August 2011 to December 2015 | 75.8%, April 2011 to March 2020 |
| Space per dollar | Compact | At the 2026-11-04 gold-silver ratio of about 78, the same dollars buy roughly 78 times the weight in silver |
Silver takes far more vault room for the same money, so ask the custodian how storage is charged before choosing between the two. For a longer look at gold's record against rising prices, see gold as an inflation hedge.
What a Gold IRA Can't Do
It can't pay you an income. Gold and silver earn no interest and no dividends. Any return comes only from the price changing between when the account buys and when it sells.
It can't promise the price will rise. FINRA notes that metals are often called safe havens, but "that doesn't make them immune from price declines." On COMEX closing prices, gold fell 44.4% between August 2011 and December 2015, and it did not close above its 2011 high again until July 2020, almost nine years later. More recently, gold closed at a record $5,318.40 on 2026-01-29 and at $4,073.00 on 2026-11-04, about 23% lower.
It can't hold costs at zero. A metals IRA has a custodian, a depository and a dealer, and each is paid. The CFTC lists "storage, insurance, administrative fees" among the costs to expect. These continue every year whether the price moves or not.
It can't be sold in one click. As the CFTC explains, a dealer sells above the spot price and buys back below it, so the round trip itself has a cost. Selling means arranging a buyer, the custodian releasing the metal, and the proceeds arriving in the account. Plan for that if you expect to need the money at a particular time.
It can't sit in your safe. The custody rule above is not optional, and taking the coins home is treated as a distribution.
None of this rules gold out. It explains why published views like the World Gold Council's description of gold as "a mainstay allocation in a well-diversified portfolio," treat it as one part of a mix. How much, if any, depends on the rest of your money; our page on how much gold to own sets out what published sources say.
Why Goldco Is Our Pick
We judge companies on what they publish and what the public record shows. Goldco is our pick for most readers who have decided they want metal in a retirement account, for five reasons.
- It publishes its minimums. Goldco's IRA product pages answer the minimum question directly: "$10,000 – Direct Purchase / $25,000 – IRA." Knowing the floor before the first call saves time on both sides.
- It handles both kinds of purchase. Goldco sells metal for self-directed IRAs and for direct delivery, so a rolled-over 401(k) and outside savings can be handled in one place, each under its own rules.
- Its buyback terms are in writing, condition included. Goldco says it will buy back metals purchased from it at any time. Its "highest price buy back guarantee applies after three years from initial purchase," and it adds "No specific buy back rates guaranteed."
- It is clear about storage. Goldco's gold IRA page states that IRA metal "must be held by an IRA custodian" and that home storage of IRA assets is illegal.
- It has a long public record. BBB lists the business as started in 2011 and rates it A+ (BBB profile, read 2026-11-19).
Who Goldco does not suit. If the amount you have in mind is under $25,000 for an IRA or $10,000 for a direct purchase, Goldco's own minimums rule it out. If you may need to sell within three years and want the highest-price guarantee to apply, the three-year condition matters. Goldco also does not name a depository on the pages we read, so if you want that settled before the first call, ask for it in writing.
The record is not spotless, and we would rather you hear it here. BBB lists 75 complaints against Goldco in the last three years (BBB profile, read 2026-11-19). In 2018, Minnesota's Department of Commerce entered a consent order finding that Goldco Direct, LLC had sold bullion to Minnesota consumers before registering as a dealer there; the company paid a $5,000 civil penalty. It was a registration matter, not a fraud finding, and Minnesota's database lists similar registration orders against several other dealers. The full picture is on our Is Goldco legit? page, and the complete Goldco review covers its products and process.
Goldco also runs its own promotion of free silver on qualifying orders*. It is Goldco's offer, it applies only to a qualifying purchase, and the terms printed at the foot of this page are the ones that count. Request the free kit and a Goldco specialist follows up by phone or email.
If you would like to compare before deciding, read our Augusta Precious Metals review, our American Hartford Gold review, or the side-by-side Goldco vs Augusta vs American Hartford Gold comparison. Our best gold IRA ranking explains the full set of criteria.
Red Flags to Walk Away From
Regulators describe the same patterns again and again. Any one is a reason to stop.
- A cold call, email or social post you didn't ask for. The CFTC's advice is direct: never buy metals because of a cold call, an unsolicited email, a social media post or an infomercial.
- Pressure to decide today. The FTC warns that scammers "create a sense of urgency" to rush people, and the CFTC lists "a false sense of urgency by claiming limited supply" as a fraud sign.
- A push toward rare or collectible coins. The CFTC says buyers of numismatic coins have been told the coins "will only go up in value," while such coins "can be difficult to objectively value."
- A "home storage IRA." The IRS treats coins the owner takes possession of as distributed. A pitch that says otherwise is a reason to end the call.
- Talk of guarantees. The SEC's alert on self-directed IRAs says fraud promoters try to convince buyers that returns are "guaranteed" or "can't miss," and adds: "Don't believe it."
- A request to move everything. No legitimate rule requires an all-or-nothing move. Being told otherwise is a sign the conversation is about the seller's interests.
FAQ
Can I keep the gold from my IRA at home?
No. IRA metal must stay in the possession of the custodian or trustee, usually at an approved depository. Coins the owner takes possession of are treated by the IRS as distributed, which can mean income tax and, before 59½, an additional tax.
Can I move an old 401(k) into a gold IRA without a tax bill?
Usually, if it is done as a direct rollover to the new IRA's custodian. If the plan pays the money to you instead, the IRS requires 20% withholding even when you intend to roll it over, and the rollover must be finished within 60 days. A tax professional can confirm how the rules apply to your plan.
What can a gold IRA hold?
Certain U.S. gold coins, the one-ounce U.S. silver coin, certain platinum coins, and gold, silver, platinum or palladium bullion that meets the fineness a regulated futures market requires. The custodian decides which specific products it accepts.
Does a gold IRA protect my savings from losing value?
No. Gold's price can and does fall. On COMEX closing prices it lost 44.4% between 2011 and 2015 and took almost nine years to regain its 2011 high.
What is Goldco's minimum?
Goldco's FAQ states $25,000 for an IRA and $10,000 for a direct purchase.
How long does setting up a gold IRA take?
It depends on the custodian you are moving money from. Goldco's silver IRA FAQ says a rollover is "Typically less than two weeks" and that metals "may take between 1 and 12 weeks to ship."
From the guides
Company Reviews
Best Gold IRA 2026: Our Top 3 Companies Compared
The best gold IRA companies for 2026 by five stated criteria: Goldco, Augusta Precious Metals and American Hartford Gold, with honest fit for each.
Company Reviews
Goldco Review: IRAs, Buyback and Who It Suits
Our Goldco review: what it sells, how its gold and silver IRA setup works, buyback, the free-silver offer's terms, ratings, and who it suits.
Company Reviews
Is Goldco Legit? Complaints, BBB and the Record
Is Goldco legit? Its BBB profile, the complaint themes customers raise, the regulatory record we found, and how to check any gold dealer yourself.
Company Reviews
Goldco vs Augusta vs American Hartford Gold
Goldco, Augusta Precious Metals and American Hartford Gold side by side: minimums as stated, products, buyback, offers and who each one suits.
Company Reviews
Augusta Precious Metals Review: Who It Suits
Augusta Precious Metals review: its stated minimum, how its gold IRA process works, storage, buyback, ratings, and the buyers it fits best.
Company Reviews
American Hartford Gold Review: Is It Legit?
American Hartford Gold review: products, gold IRA setup, buyback, ratings and complaints, and whether it's the right fit for your order.
Gold IRA Basics
How to Buy Gold in an IRA, Step by Step
How to buy gold in an IRA: open a self-directed account, move the money without a tax bill, choose eligible metal and arrange approved storage.
Gold IRA Basics
Robinhood Gold IRA Match vs a Precious Metals IRA
Robinhood Gold is a subscription, not gold metal. How its IRA match works, what a precious metals IRA is instead, and how the two compare.
Gold and Your Money
How Much Gold to Own: What Sources Say
How much gold should you own? The ranges published sources give, who gives them, why the answer depends on the rest of your money, and what to ask.
Gold and Your Money
Gold and Inflation: What the Record Shows
Does gold keep up with inflation? What the price and CPI record shows across different decades, when it worked, when it didn't, and why.
Sources
- 26 U.S. Code § 408, including 408(m) on collectibles
- IRS Publication 590-B, Distributions from IRAs
- IRS: Rollovers of retirement plan and IRA distributions
- IRS: Retirement topics, required minimum distributions
- CDC NCHS Data Brief 548, Mortality in the United States, 2024
- Administration for Community Living, 2023 Profile of Older Americans
- U.S. Census Bureau, Number, Timing, and Duration of Marriages and Divorces: 2009
- CFTC: questions for metals buyers (joint bulletin with FINRA, 2024)
- FINRA: the same joint bulletin
- FINRA: tips on physical precious metals, March 2026
- CFTC: Fraud advisory on precious metals
- CFTC: Gold and silver schemes designed to drain retirement savings
- SEC: Self-directed IRAs and the risk of fraud
- FTC: Scams to watch for
- World Gold Council: gold as a strategic asset, 2026 edition
- Goldco: Start a gold IRA (FAQ, minimums)
- Goldco: Start a silver IRA (FAQ)
- Goldco: buyback guarantee terms
- Goldco: gold IRA and home storage
- Goldco BBB profile
- Minnesota Department of Commerce enforcement actions: Goldco
- COMEX gold and silver futures daily closes, 2000 to 2026-11-04 (Yahoo Finance), computed by Smart Woman Gold